Adventures with Beethoven

Scene Three

A Deaf Musician: Beethoven and Disability

 
 

One of the most well-known facts about Beethoven is that he was deaf. It’s hard to imagine how much this affected him. For anyone, losing a sense is difficult. But, for a musician, whose life was based on experiencing sound, becoming deaf was devastating.

Beethoven began losing his hearing around 1798 when he was still relatively young, only 28 years old. Beethoven attributed the start of his hearing problems to a fit he had over a disagreement with a singer with whom he was working. His hearing faded slowly over time and he also had a severe case of tinnitus, or ringing in the ears. In 1801 Beethoven wrote letters to several friends describing his hearing problems and how it made it difficult to work and to be around others. It became increasingly difficult for Beethoven to understand what people were saying when he was in a crowded room. Although he acknowledged these issues in his letters, his friends had probably already noticed the changes in Beethoven.

In 1802 Beethoven followed his doctor’s advice and moved to the small town of Heiligenstadt (hi-lig-in-sh-tot), Austria just outside of Vienna. He spent six months there from April to October. During his time away from Vienna, Beethoven tried to come to terms with what losing his hearing would mean to his professional life. While there, he wrote a lengthy letter to his younger brothers, Karl and Johann. In the document, called the Heiligenstadt Testament, Beethoven wrote about his thoughts and feelings about becoming deaf. At one point in the letter, he was so despondent, he contemplated suicide. By the end of the letter, Beethoven had decided he was going to live his life and face whatever fate dealt him. He vowed to live through and for his art. Although this is one of the most personal documents Beethoven ever wrote, he never sent it to his brothers. It was discovered among his papers after his death in 1827.

A facsimile of the Heiligenstadt Testament, from Wikipedia

A facsimile of the Heiligenstadt Testament, from Wikipedia

In letters to friends from the same time period, Beethoven is never quite as depressed as he was in the Heiligenstadt Testament. He wrote to one friend that he would, “seize Fate by the throat; it shall certainly not crush me completely.” In one of his manuscripts from 1806 he wrote “Let your deafness no longer be a secret — even in art.” (Learn more in the Scene Three section titled “The Heiligenstadt Testament.”) 

After returning to Vienna from Heiligenstadt, Beethoven continued with his work, featuring a new compositional style. Beethoven wrote to a friend, fellow composer Carl Czerny (Chur-knee), that “I am not satisfied with the work I have done so far. From now on I intend to take a new way.” The first work of this new era, often called Beethoven’s “heroic” period by scholars, was his Symphony No. 3, Eroica (Heroic) written in 1803-04. When the work premiered in 1805 it was Beethoven’s longest piece ever, lasting almost an hour. Although some listeners didn’t understand its structure or ideas, others thought it was a masterpiece. Beethoven wrote some of his greatest works during this period, including Symphonies 4-8, his only opera, Fidelio, and his Violin Concerto. Beethoven earned money from the publication and performance of his works. He also earned money by performing concerts himself; however, as his hearing got worse, these performances became more and more difficult. 

18th-century drawing of ear trumpets by Frederick Dekkers, from Wikipedia

18th-century drawing of ear trumpets by Frederick Dekkers, from Wikipedia

Beethoven’s final public performances as a soloist were in the spring of 1814. Louis Spohr, another composer, said “the piano was badly out of tune, which Beethoven minded little, since he did not hear it…there was scarcely anything left of the virtuosity of the artist…I was deeply saddened.” Beethoven had always been a virtuoso performer; he could play everything he heard, he could play from memory, and improvise. To be unable to perform any longer was an emotional, as well as financial, blow to Beethoven.

From 1814 on Beethoven used ear-trumpets to help him hear better. The trumpets were funnel-shaped devices made of metal, wood, snail shells, or animal horns. The idea was that the trumpet would collect the sounds and lead them into the ear, magnifying the sounds and allowing the user to hear better. Beethoven’s ear-trumpets were made by Johann Nepomuk Mälzel, who was best known for making one of the first metronomes, a small, mechanical device that keeps a precise rhythm.

From 1815-1819 Beethoven composed very few pieces. He was sick for more than a year and had ongoing legal problems with his family (See “Beethoven’s Family” in Scene One). He did write a few works, including the Piano Sonata No. 29 in B Flat Major, Hammerklavier, and wrote some ideas that he would later use in his Ninth Symphony. By 1818, Beethoven was finally feeling better; however, over the course of his illness his hearing had deteriorated even further. By now, even the ear-trumpets were not helping. In order to communicate with people, Beethoven used notebooks to write to friends. These “conversation books” are a valuable resource that tell us a lot about Beethoven and his life. Some of the conversations are everyday events detailing visits from friends and household maintenance. Others however tell us about Beethoven’s thoughts on music as an art form and give specific instructions about how he intended his music to be performed.

Beethoven’s “conversation notebooks”, from TopTenz.net “Top 10 Historically Important Notebooks”

Beethoven’s “conversation notebooks”, from TopTenz.net “Top 10 Historically Important Notebooks”

Over the last decade of his life, Beethoven continued to compose. He finished several large works including the Diabelli Variations and Missa Solemnis. He was often sick for extended periods of time, but continued to work, even when ill. He also completed his final symphony. The Ninth Symphony was performed in Vienna for the first time on May 7, 1824. Beethoven stood next to the orchestra director Michael Umlauf during the performance. Beethoven beat time to lead the orchestra, even though he couldn’t hear much, if any, of the music. Umlauf had already warned the orchestra and chorus to ignore Beethoven during the concert. At the end, someone had to turn Beethoven around so that he could witness the applause, since he couldn’t hear it. It must have been an amazing thing to witness, not only the premiere of perhaps the greatest symphony in history, but the human moment when Beethoven turned around and saw the reception to his work.