Theme and Variation
In The Young Person’s Guide to the Orchestra, Britten uses a musical form called Theme and Variations. The main theme is first played by the entire orchestra, then as the piece progresses, each section plays a variation of the theme. While they are all based on the main musical idea, each one is slightly different. In some of the versions, it’s really easy to hear the main theme, in others it’s more hidden.
It may sound a little boring for an entire piece of music to be based on one idea. Instead, it makes it like a musical puzzle, for both the composer and the listener. How can each variation be interesting?
Britten sets each variation with its own unique mood, tempo, and idea. He also changes the accompaniment, the music underneath the main melody, to contrast the two parts. When the clarinets have their melody, they are accompanied by the tuba. For the trumpet, the accompaniment is in the snare drum and strings playing pizzicato (plucking instead of bowing). Many composers have written Theme and Variations, sometimes to use a favorite melody of a fellow composer, sometimes to write a piece that shows off the technical virtuosity of a performer, and sometimes to test their creativity.
Check out these other examples of Theme and Variations!
Twelve Variations on “Ah vous dirai-je, Maman” by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Mozart wrote this set of variations for piano in 1781 or 1782. Although the title looks complicated, the melody is the one you might know as “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star.” In each of the twelve versions, it’s easy to hear the tune. In the first variation, Mozart adds extra notes to make the melody more complicated. In the fifth variation, he changes the rhythm, shifting what we expect to hear. In the seventh, Mozart changes the harmony, giving it a different sound. In the eighth variation, he shifts the key entirely, moving it from a major key, to a minor one.
Diabelli Variations by Ludwig van Beethoven
Beethoven wrote the Diabelli Variations for piano between 1819-1823. The work is based on a waltz composed by the Austrian composer Anton Diabelli. In 1819, Diabelli sent his composition to all the important composers in Austria, including Franz Schubert, Carl Czerny, and Beethoven. Diabelli asked each composer to write a variation on it and he would then publish the collection to raise money for orphans and widows after the Napoleonic Wars. Supposedly, Beethoven originally refused to participate because he thought the theme was boring. However, when he found out how much Diabelli would pay for a whole set of variations, Beethoven changed his mind and decided to show what he could do with a small bit of music. In other stories, Beethoven felt “insulted” for being asked to work with such a bad main theme and wrote a lot of music to show off his skills.
Whatever the reason, Beethoven eventually agreed to participate in the project. However, instead of writing only one variation for the charity publication, Beethoven
wrote thirty-three. Rather than using Diabelli’s entire melody, Beethoven used only part of it, a simple opening motif and elaborately developed it. Beethoven writes in a wide variety of styles and speeds, some are slow and tender, while others and exciting and fast. Many scholars and music critics consider the Diabelli Variations to be one of the greatest piano pieces ever written.
Goldberg Variations by Johann Sebastian Bach
Johann Sebastian Bach wrote the Goldberg Variations in 1741. They were named after Johann Gottlieb Goldberg who took lessons with Bach. According to an early biography of Bach, Goldberg suffered from insomnia and his employer asked Bach to write some pieces for Goldberg that he could play when he couldn’t sleep. Bach originally wrote this work for harpsichord (the piano was still in its early years of use), however today, performers often play it on the piano.
Bach presents the aria, the main theme at the beginning of the piece. Instead of using the melody of the theme as the basis for the subsequent variations, Bach uses the bass line and chord progressions to create the thirty variations. The variations are divided into ten groups of three with each group including a virtuosic piece, a gentle, lyrical piece, and a canon, a piece where the melodic voices imitate each other (like singing a song as a round, such as “Row, Row, Row Your Boat). After all thirty variations, Bach then has the performer repeat the opening aria to close the work. The Goldberg Variations features amazing technical writing with gorgeous lyrical melodies that achieve the pinnacle of keyboard music.
Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini
Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini is a one-movement work for piano and orchestra written by Sergei Rachmaninoff in 1934. The piece features twenty-four variations based on one of the Caprices for Solo Violin by Niccolò Paganini, an 18th century violin virtuoso and composer. The work has three main sections, roughly corresponding to the three movements of a standard concerto, variations one through ten are the opening movement, variations eleven through eighteen are the slow section, and the remaining variations make up the finale. Rachmaninoff opens with a short introduction, then starts with a variation, before the main theme is introduced in the piano. The most famous part of the piece is the eighteenth variation which has been used in many tv shows, movies, and video games. In it Rachmaninoff presents the melody in inversion, the melody is played upside down, where all the jumps and skips in the melody go the opposite way from the original melody. Several other composers used this theme as a set of variations (Robert Schumann, Franz Liszt, and Johannes Brahms). Rachmaninoff created his own original work that has remained an audience favorite.
Variations on a Theme of Haydn
Johannes Brahms wrote Variations on a Theme by Joseph Haydn (also called the Saint Anthony Variations) in 1873. He wrote two versions of the piece, one for two pianos and one for orchestra. The orchestral version is most often performed. The work features the theme based on a tune for wind band called “Chorale St. Antoni,” followed by eight variations and a finale. When Brahms found the music,
Franz Joseph Haydn was listed as the composer. Often in the early 19th century, publishers would attribute music written by lesser-known composers to more famous ones in order to sell more copies. Most likely, this tune was not written by Haydn, but scholars aren’t sure who did compose it. Since it was most likely not written by Haydn, some orchestras list the work as the Saint Anthony Variations instead.
The theme is a ten-measure passage broken into two five-measure phrases. This odd number of measures was unusual and may have been what attracted Brahms to the melody. He used this phrase structure in each of the variations, changing the character of each variation. Near the end of the finale, Brahms quotes a melody from Haydn’s “Clock” symphony, so even if the main theme wasn’t really written by Haydn, Brahms included something of Haydn in his piece.
Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge
This is another set of variations written by Benjamin Britten. In 1932, after five years studying with Frank Bridge, Britten began writing a piece based on a theme from one of Bridge’s works as a tribute to his teacher. However, Britten was distracted by other work and didn’t finish the piece. In 1937, organizers at the Salzburg Festival invited conductor Boyd Neel and his orchestra to perform. One of the works needed to be a previously unperformed work by a British composer.
Neel had worked with Britten before and asked him to write a piece for string orchestra, to be performed in just three months. Rather than simply reviving what he had started, Britten began a new set of variations based on a different melody by Bridge. Based on the theme from the second of Bridge’s Three Idylls for string quartet, Britten had a first draft done in ten days and finished the work soon after.
The work is for string orchestra and was premiered first on the radio and then two days later at the festival. Following the introduction, Britten wrote ten variations, including a waltz, a funeral march, and a fugue. Britten wrote each section to highlight a quality of Bridge’s personality, including integrity, charm, humor, and sympathy. Britten dedicated the work “To F.B. A tribute with affection and admiration.”
For New York (Variations on Themes of Leonard Bernstein)
Although best known for his movie soundtracks, John Williams has written numerous works for the concert hall. In 1988, to celebrate the 70th birthday of fellow composer and conductor Leonard Bernstein, Williams wrote a one-movement piece based on themes from Bernstein’s musicals On the Town and West Side Story. At the end, Williams also adds snippets of “Happy Birthday to You.” The work was performed by the Boston Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Williams on the last day of a birthday gala for Bernstein at the Tanglewood Music Center.
Variations on “America”
Charles Ives wrote this piece in 1891 when he was seventeen and first performed the work the following year at an Independence Day celebration. It is based on the tune “America (My Country, ’Tis of Thee),” which at the time, was used as a national anthem for the United States. After Ives first performed the work, on organ at the church where he was employed, he revised it for the next couple of years. The work was not published until 1949 when an organist rediscovered it and it has become a popular piece for organists. In 1962, William Schuman arranged the work for orchestra. A version for wind band was published in 1968. Following an introduction and theme there are five variations and two interludes concluding with a coda. The interludes are Ives’ first notated use of bitonality, where two different keys are used at the same time. The organ version has very tricky sections, especially the pedal work in the final variation, which Ives said was “almost as much fun as playing baseball.” Ives was known for his satire and musical jokes, although he most likely wrote this piece as a serious organ exercise, he noted his father “didn’t let me do it much, as it made the boys laugh” in church.
Variations on “I Got Rhythm”
George Gershwin composed this set of variations for piano and orchestra during a three week vacation in 1934. He dedicated the work to his brother and collaborator, Ira. Gershwin was set to go on a concert tour and wanted another showpiece to play as an alternative to his Rhapsody in Blue and Concerto in F. This piece is based on his popular song “I Got Rhythm” from the musical Girl Crazy. The piece starts with clarinets which is answered by the piano then the orchestra joins in. After a statement of the theme, the variations are in the styles of a waltz, an atonal version, an Asian inspired version, a jazz section, a variation where the treble and bass sections are inverted, and then a grand finale. The piece, as Gershwin intended, is a rousing crowd-pleaser based on a well-loved tune.
Paraphrases
This set of twenty-four variations for piano features contributions from Russian composers Alexander Borodin, Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov, César Cui, and Anatoly Lyadov. Supposedly Borodin’s young daughter Gania wanted to play a duet with her father, however the only piece she knew was a simple song that we recognize as “Chopsticks.” Borodin improvised several variations while playing with his daughter and then asked his friends to contribute to the piece.